Social [OR] Media — Which Is Best for You?
The social media space has seen extreme ups and downs over the last 30 years; yes, the term was first coined in 1994. Additionally, as businesses got into the social space, social channels—increasingly looking for ways to monetize—began building a pay-to-play world where organic engagement rarely happens without viral momentum. As such, social media tends to skew more media than social. Yet, while this fact can be understood, where does the actual power lie?
Provocation 1: Social Media is an Algorithm-Driven Megaphone
Social media platforms have increasingly shifted toward being algorithm-driven megaphones, prioritizing paid content over organic reach. In 2022, Meta's algorithm update favored content from ads and creator partnerships over organic posts, reducing non-sponsored reach by up to 20% for some businesses. This shift is, in part, a direct response to a saturated market where platforms rely on ad revenue to thrive. For strategists, the initial implication is clear: social media, as a "media-buying platform," benefits brands that pay for visibility. It may also signal the death of authentic brand engagement on these platforms.
According to a 2023 study by eMarketer, nearly 60% of all business-related posts on Instagram failed to reach their intended audience unless bolstered by paid ads. TikTok's latest algorithm updates similarly push brands toward paid promotions as their organic reach decreases due, in part, to crowded feeds and intense competition for attention. For brands with limited budgets, relying on paid media creates a dangerous dependency. Short-term mini-wins from paid amplification are common, but long-term audience engagement falters without meaningful community-building efforts.
Implication 1: Algorithm Reliance is Unsustainable
For businesses, the heavy reliance on algorithms for visibility is a short-term tactic that can damage long-term brand equity. While paid ads may ensure immediate visibility, they fail to nurture the kind of emotional connections that foster loyalty and advocacy. To succeed, businesses must integrate paid media with organic community-building efforts, using social platforms as a two-way communication channel rather than a one-sided broadcast system.
Provocation 2: Community as an Organic Pathway to Engagement
Despite the overwhelming influence of algorithms, successful brands recognize that community-building is the key to fostering sustainable engagement. The primary hurdle for brands is to construct communities that inspire users to engage, without algorithms dictating the interaction with content willingly.
A 2023 report from Sprout Social highlights that brands that prioritize creating community rather than just broadcasting ads see 50% more long-term brand loyalty and 34% higher engagement rates across platforms. This statistic suggests an untapped opportunity to move beyond using social platforms as megaphones and instead transform them into collaborative spaces where people participate in brand storytelling. For example, Patagonia consistently outperforms other outdoor brands on social platforms not by investing in massive ad buys but by nurturing a community that reflects its values of environmental sustainability. Patagonia’s ”1% for the Planet” initiative sparked user-generated content and real-world activism, creating a sense of belonging around the brand’s cause.
Implication 2: Social Media is a Tool built for Belonging, Not Just Broadcasting
Strategists and businesses must shift their understanding of social media from a megaphone to a network for cultivating belonging. To build meaningful connections, brands must design content that is not just valuable, but also sparks organic conversation and voluntary interaction. Community-focused content fosters not only brand loyalty, but also advocacy, where customers become brand ambassadors. The strategic focus should be on facilitating user-driven narratives that shape how brands are perceived over time, rather than relying solely on ads.
Provocation 3: Engagement Requires Intentional Content Design
The distinction between using social media to simply push content versus building a community rests in intentionality. Brands must be deliberate in designing content that fosters interaction, conversation, and a sense of ownership among the audience. Paid media can drive awareness, but community-driven content keeps the audience invested in the brand, making them active participants in shaping its identity.
Research from HubSpot (2023) revealed that 75% of consumers want to feel connected to brands, with 64% indicating that they are more likely to engage with brands that respond directly to their posts and comments. This finding underscores the need for a shift in strategy—from content designed for passive consumption to content that sparks dialogue and interaction. Successful examples include Starbucks' "My Starbucks Idea," a crowdsourcing platform that engaged customers in creating new products and menu ideas, fostering an ongoing conversation with the brand rather than one-off, transactional interactions.
Implication 3: Data-Driven Insights for Human-Centric Engagement
To fully leverage social media as a community-building tool, businesses must move away from vanity metrics like views and likes and embrace deeper engagement metrics such as authentic conversations, content shares with personal commentary, and ongoing interactions. Strategies must redefine KPIs to reflect engagement quality, not just the quantity of exposure. Success is measured in lasting relationships, not just fleeting impressions.
Provocation 4: Metrics That Matter—From Impressions to Connection
In the traditional model of algorithm-based engagement, success is often measured in views, likes, or shares, metrics that offer little insight into true brand impact. However, brands focusing on community prioritize metrics that reflect deeper engagement—such as comments, shares with meaningful captions, and user-generated content that reflects personal connections to the brand.
According to a 2022 Nielsen report, brands that engage audiences meaningfully see a 30% higher customer lifetime value compared to those focused on metrics like impressions. The implication for strategists is clear: measuring success based solely on views has never been it. Engagement metrics that indicate emotional connection and active participation should take precedence. Brands that emphasize community-first strategies, such as Glossier and REI, have successfully transitioned from product peddlers to traveling the path to becoming cultural icons by focusing on the depth of their interactions rather than the breadth of their reach.
Conclusion: The URGENT NEED FOR A Strategic Shift from Megaphone to Community
In the current digital landscape, social media presents brands with two distinct paths—pay-to-play visibility or the cultivation of meaningful engagement through community building. While algorithm-driven media buying may offer quick wins, its long-term sustainability is in doubt without the organic, community-first approach that fosters sustained brand loyalty. It is the role of strategists to spearhead this shift by crafting content that prioritizes connection over impression, dialogue over broadcast, and meaning over reach. They must find ways to entice people to actively visit their social channels, thereby promoting a community-first strategy.
P.S.: Is Nutter Butter OK?